StanChart’s takeover defences are getting stronger

LONDON: At any point in the past half-decade or so, Standard Chartered shareholders would probably have welcomed an all-cash takeover as a blessed salvation. The bank struggled with high costs and low returns, leading to a bombed-out valuation. But that’s changing, which could make life trickier for possible bidders like First Abu Dhabi Bank.

The bank run by Bill Winters on Thursday reported an 8% return on tangible equity (ROTE) for 2022, after stripping out restructuring costs and other one-offs. That’s the best result the former JPMorgan (JPM.N) executive has reported since taking charge in 2015. This year, he reckons the bank will churn out a near-10% return, rising to more than 11% in 2024.

StanChart’s improving prospects complicate matters for FAB. The $43 billion Gulf lender said in January it had evaluated an offer for the $26 billion group but was no longer doing so. It reiterated that position last Friday in response to reports that it was still working on a bid. Persuading StanChart shareholders to sell would have been easier a few years ago, when the bank was valued at less than half of its tangible book value and seemed years away from earning a return close to its cost of equity of perhaps 10%. But if Winters can convince investors his new targets are remotely plausible, he’ll have a stronger case for StanChart’s independence.

Investors, admittedly, are still sceptical. Despite a boost from takeover speculation, StanChart shares trade at roughly two-thirds of its expected tangible book value at the end of 2023, implying that future returns will be closer to the bad old days. That seems unfair. Interest rates are rising and China, a key market, has loosened pandemic restrictions. Winters’ targeted returns assume annual revenue growth of between 8% and 10%, less than the 16% increase in the bank’s top line in 2022, after stripping out currency fluctuations.

Besides, StanChart’s concentrated ownership could help. Singaporean state investor Temasek owns 16.4%, according to Refinitiv data, while the top five shareholders together hold 36% of the company. If they agree with Winters’ vision of future returns, they’re more likely to demand a higher-than-usual premium from FAB or another bargain-hunter. A typical offer pitched 30% above the price before the latest takeover speculation would value StanChart at just three-quarters of forward tangible book value. StanChart’s stronger takeover defences may be a problem for its suitors.

CONTEXT NEWS

Standard Chartered on Feb. 16 said it generated $16.3 billion of revenue in 2022, up 10% from 2021. Excluding the effects of foreign-exchange fluctuations the increase was 16%.

The bank’s costs increased by 4% to $10.7 billion, which was a 9% rise in constant-currency terms.

StanChart earned an 8% return on tangible equity (ROTE), excluding restructuring expenses and a writedown of goodwill on the bank’s balance sheet. Chief Executive Bill Winters said he expected to hit a ROTE of almost 10% in 2023 and more than 11% next year.

StanChart shares were up 3.5% to 755 pence as of 0838 GMT on Feb. 16.

First Abu Dhabi Bank, the United Arab Emirates’ biggest lender, on Feb. 10 said it was not evaluating an offer for Standard Chartered, the second time it quashed reports of a deal.

News of the potential offer first came on Jan. 5, when FAB said it had considered a bid for London-listed Standard Chartered but was no longer doing so.

Must Read

Honda, Nissan agree to discuss merger forming world’s third-largest automaker

The combined entity projects to generate $191 billion in revenue, $19 billion profit, with Honda nominating majority board members