IHC orders CDA to seal ‘illegal’ navy club

IHC CJ says 'no one is above the law, not even courts'

ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad High Court (IHC) has ordered the Capital Development Authority (CDA) administration to seal the newly-constructed Navy Sailing Club, declaring the sports complex’s construction illegal.

Two weeks ago, the CDA had served a notice to the navy for its allegedly illegal and unauthorised construction of the club and directed to immediately stop the construction of the building.

During the hearing on Thursday, a board member told the court that the CDA had not issued any allotment letter for the land in question. To which, IHC Chief Justice Athar Minallah asked if the authority had taken any action to halt the construction. “We had issued notices to the navy,” the CDA representative informed the judge.

“What do you mean ‘you issued notices’” asked Justice Minallah.”Demolish the building.”

Last week, the navy had clarified that the land in question was, in fact, allotted to it in 1994 for the development of a water sports centre. A statement issued at the time had asserted that navy divers are trained at the club who, then, take part in rescue operations in all four provinces and the federally administrative units, including Azad Jammu and Kashmir, as the club is the only such facility in the north of the country.

Citing a 1994 order of the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO), the CDA official informed the court that the permission to build the sports facility was granted by prime minister of the day, Benazir Bhutto.

However, the judge ordered the CDA to seal the facility before the next hearing, saying in case the authority fails to comply, the court will summon Cabinet Secretary Ahmad Nawaz Sukhera. He also directed the issue to be presented before the cabinet.

The judge wondered if the flagship military project was supported by any legal provision providing space for a purportedly commercial project.

When a Pakistan Navy representative, who was present in the court, sought time to submit a response, Justice Minallah asked what did the navy need time for. “We respect you, appreciate your sacrifices and honour your martyrs but an illegal construction isn’t allowed,” he said.

“Why are you defending something which is indefensible [according to relevant laws],” he questioned.

“Islamabad is the country’s capital, not a tribal area. No one is above the law. Not even this court.”

- Advertisement -


  1. taking action against any illegal activity is good for providing justice but acting against state institutions so rapidly is not understandable , why our superior court is so aggressive in the instant case ? the same courts don’t take harsh or speedy action against corrupt politicians or judges or bureaucrats except in favor , that’s really strange

  2. Good decision no one is above the law,civilian bussiness hubs and illegal construction are demolished in just matter of days so those who above saying that anyone institution is above law need to get his/her hypocrisy test.

  3. Good decision provided it can be implemented.I foresee that y this time decision must have been held by a stay order through supreme court or an executive order by PM,legalizing the construction as he has to obey orders from his selectors to remain in office

Comments are closed.

- Advertisement -

Must Read

Honda repudiates rumours of delaying or putting off the Honda HR-V

LAHORE: Honda Atlas Cars Pakistan Limited (HACPL) has dismissed various media reports that HACPL will either delay or outright put off the launch of...