Recipe for sustained growth of jobs in Pakistan to meet youth bulge


They ask me to give ideas for increasing employment in Pakistan. The answer they are expecting is build more industry, more industrial parks, build SEZs and seek more FDI. And of course, don’t forget to give everybody a low-quality education and then pray graduates get a job!

Policy in Pakistan has danced to the music of these clichés emanating from donor consulting jobs. The results are there for all to see, galloping debt, declining productivity and repeated IMF programs.

The only real employment and poverty reduction opportunity that our poor have got is from migration and sending remittances back to their families.

Pakistan economy has grown on average at about 5% per annum not because of government policy but despite it. The sectors that policy has favored — agriculture and education have shrunk despite subsidies. Growth of the economy and jobs has happened in the services sector: education finance, telephony and media.

We can learn something from these facts.

1. Policy and our thinkers have been stuck in a groove. Despite mounting evidence, they lack originality and innovation.

2. Growth does not follow government, policy or the consultant.

3. Jobs are mostly being created in places that policy and consultant don’t expect.

4. Growth happens and jobs are created where there is demand even if government is trying to move the economy in another direction.

What few understand is that jobs are created in markets and not sectors or other fanciful thoughts of clever speakers.

What then can policy and government do?

Create competitive markets with proper regulation based on monitoring and evaluation. Such markets must seek to reward innovation and entrepreneurship. This will require thoughtful and well researched policies and regulation. It will require a reinvention of our government procedures that currently are very suspicious of the market.

To see this, consider the growth drivers of the last 2 decades: education, telephones and TV. Growth and entrepreneurship opened up in these areas as they were opened up.

History has shown us that jobs open up in vibrant cities. For this reason, rural populations flow into cities. If cities are unfriendly to migration and development, there is no space for markets entrepreneurship and innovation. We have seen badly regulated cities deny space to poor housing, offices, commerce, trade, entertainment and other city spaces.

Historically market have situated in cities to host innovation and entrepreneurship. Such cities are a hotbed of commerce, trade and ideas. Such dynamic cites are an everchanging amalgam of tower cranes signaling the continued construction of fresh space that economic activity wants.

It is immediately obvious what is holding back both market development as well as vibrant city development is the centralized hold of the persisting colonial administration, judicial and legal system.

The consultant approach is to draw up long to do lists, ranging from rearranging the room to a laundry list of large expensive projects. But our systemic view here shows that deep reform is the areas of governance, market and city reform will generate sustained growth rates north of 8% for over 20 years and quite likely meet the employment needs of our youthful population.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here