The Competition Appellate Tribunal (CAT) has dismissed the appeal filed by M/s Karachi Nimko, upholding the Competition Commission of Pakistan’s (CCP) decision to impose a Rs20 million fine for deceptive marketing practices and trademark infringement.
The appeal was dismissed due to non-pursuance by the company—marking the second time the Tribunal has taken this step on the same grounds. After the initial dismissal, the appellant successfully sought restoration of the case; however, repeated non-appearance by its legal counsel led to a final dismissal.
The Tribunal also expressed dissatisfaction with the company’s apparent delaying tactics.
The case originated from a 2019 complaint lodged by M/s Nimco Corner, accusing competitors M/s Nimko Corner and M/s Karachi Nimko of copying its trademark, packaging, and trade dress. Following an in-depth inquiry, the CCP concluded that both companies had violated Section 10 of the Competition Act, 2010, by engaging in misleading and deceptive marketing.
Investigations revealed the unauthorized replication of branding elements that misled consumers and disrupted fair competition in the marketplace. Both companies acknowledged the infringement. Consequently, the CCP imposed penalties of Rs25 million on M/s Nimko Corner and Rs20 million on M/s Karachi Nimko.
The Commission also ordered both businesses to cease the use of infringing materials and submit a compliance report outlining corrective actions.
